Ga direct naar de inhoud

Real estate transfer tax reorganisation exemption: Dutch Supreme Court prioritises economic interest over legal ownership

Published on: November 12, 2026
Type of publication Insight
Related topics

For real estate transactions within a group, an exemption of real estate transfer tax (RETT) may often be available. But is legal ownership of all shares sufficient to qualify as a group for these purposes?

The Dutch Supreme Court recently delivered an important judgment addressing this matter. At the heart of the case was the interpretation of the term interest in a case where legal ownership and economic interest in shares were effectively separated within a real estate structure.

Our experts discuss the judgment and its potential implications for other tax provisions and taxes.

When does the reorganisation exemption apply for real estate transfer tax?

The case concerned a real estate fund structure in which the sole legal shareholder of several companies was a fund manager. The economic returns generated by those companies were allocated to fund participants under agreements between the fund and the fund manager.

As part of an internal restructuring, shares in a real estate entity (onroerendezaakrechtspersoon, or ‘OZR’) were transferred within the structure. To prevent Dutch real estate transfer tax from being levied on the transaction, the internal reorganisation exemption was applied. One of the conditions for applying this exemption is that an interest of at least 90% exists within the group structure.

Both the District Court and the Court of Appeal held that the concept of interest should be linked to the shareholding. As there was only one class of shares, they concluded that the entire interest was held by the legal shareholder, meaning that the requirements for the internal reorganisation exemption were met.

Supreme Court: economic interest takes precedence over legal ownership

The Dutch Supreme Court took a different approach.

According to the Supreme Court, the decisive factor is who holds the entire, or virtually the entire, economic interest. This includes essentially all, or virtually all, risks associated with fluctuations in value and the potential loss of value of the shares in the group companies. Legal ownership of the shares is not decisive factor.

As the fund participants did not form part of the group for the purposes of the exemption, the internal reorganisation exemption could not be applied.

What does this judgment mean for real estate funds and group structures?

The effects of this judgment may extend beyond the specific fund structure considered in the case. The Supreme Court appears to interpret the concept of interest within the framework of the Dutch Taxes on Legal Transactions Act (Wet belastingen van rechtsverkeer) from a distinctly economic perspective.

For real estate investors and businesses, this means that it is no longer sufficient to focus solely on legal shareholder relationships. In fund structures, trust office (STAK) arrangements and management structures, it will become increasingly important to assess where the economic risks, returns and value developments actually lie.

Link with the Capital Directive

The Supreme Court also considered whether the European Capital Directive was applicable. Recent case law from the EU Court of Justice indicates that, in certain circumstances, the aforementioned Directive may apply to the acquisition of shares in an OZR, in which case the transaction may be tax-exempt.

According to the Supreme Court, it had not been established that the transactions in question were of a type that must remain outside the scope of indirect taxation under the Capital Directive. Nevertheless, the Supreme Court appears to confirm that the Directive may indeed be relevant for Dutch real estate transfer tax in cases involving the acquisition of shares in an OZR. This could mean that, in certain situations, the Directive offers a broader exemption than is currently available under Dutch legislation.

Could this judgment affect other tax legislation?

The judgment concerns the application of the internal reorganisation exemption. It is possible that its impact may extend to other provisions in the Dutch Taxes on Legal Transactions Act and related policy decrees in which the concept of interest plays a role.

However, caution is required when applying the judgment to other taxes. Terms such as interest, shareholding and economic interest generally have their own specific legal meaning in other areas of tax law. That said, the judgment may provide useful guidance when interpreting other legislation. Where the law does not explicitly refer to legal ownership, the economic reality of an arrangement may prove decisive.

Businesses and investors with real estate structures in which legal ownership and economic interest are separated should monitor these developments closely.

Would you like to know what these developments may mean for your business, investment or group structure? Our real estate specialists would be happy to discuss the implications with you.

The legislation and regulations in this area may be subject to change. We recommend that you discuss the potential impact of this with your Baker Tilly advisor.

Contact our experts

Govinda Kandhai

Director VAT Advisory

Tim Visser

Sr. Manager Tax Advisory

Other insights

    No results found